Before continuing, please be aware that all of this content is made possible by the goodwill and support of my backers on Patreon. If you enjoy the work on this site, please consider supporting the creation of more content like this by clicking the button.
Oh boy, The Sandman. This one opens with that glorious old-school forehead slap: humans Mordecan and Nintaru describe themselves as “space gypsies.” Yeah, that term jumps right off the page like an unlicensed tattoo—it’s a slur, not your average alien descriptor, and we don’t get anything resembling awareness or critique from the script. That’s not my label—that’s theirs—but in 2025, come on. The moment they throw that slur into the narrative, your antenna go up, and you never fully get them down again.
So, Sixth Doctor and Evelyn arrive aboard a migratory vessel of the Clutch—a wandering society of Galyari (imagine Zerg meets Tyranids meets somehow articulate puppets). They believe the Doctor is their mythical Sandman, a terror-god who devours their “memory eggs.” Naturally, Colin Baker leans into the menace: coat swirling, voice dropping, eyebrow doing that “I’m not scary, you are” thing. Evelyn is disturbed by the suggestion that his coat might literally be made of Galyari hide, but for us listeners… come on. We know the Doc is playing a part, not eating aliens for dinner.
But the mythology around the eggs (the Shrush‑kubbrrr? Or maybe Shrush‑bobble?) is vague at best and frustratingly inconsistent—each actor pronounces it differently, so we never quite lock down the spelling, pronunciation, or power. The plot: the Doctor once destroyed one egg ages ago to stop a Galyari invasion. Now a new egg spawns horrific visions, and the Clutch are on the warpath again. The Doc recruits Mordecan (the titular “space Romani Traveller,” not to be confused with interstellar SU scientist) and Nintaru (bird-person sidekick) and then… flap some wings, emit some bird-sounds, and the day is kind of saved. Did the egg explode? Who knows. All I remember is bird squawks and SFX.
That question the story wants to ask—“Can we do monstrously heroic things, then live with the legacy?”—never actually lands. It’s like setting up a labyrinth but skipping aisle three so you just hang out in the gift shop. You should get Morally Ambiguous Doctor, whole trenches of emotional fallout, centuries of guilt. But instead: fluff. The Doctor never feels ambiguous.
Had the storyy made set before the myth existed—with the Doc arriving having never before met the Galyari and hearing these awful legends about himself for the first time—that could’ve been something. A tight little time-loop where the Doctor ponders, “Do I have to do this awful thing, to be remembered performing it?” But no.
The Galyari themselves are bland. They wail, they curse, they worship their terror-god. But they never feel lived-in, never feel like a culture you could accidentally step into and get lost. The Clutch? Barely a setting.
Final thoughts?
This had all the ingredients of a cult-classic: cosmic horror, cosmic regret, cosmic mythology—and maybe a cosmic villain-turned-friend. Instead, it’s a decorative alien bedtime story with echoes and wings and zero heft. The medical reading on the Doctor’s legacy? Flatline.
2 out of 5 unsettling lullabies