Before continuing, please be aware that all of this content is made possible by the goodwill and support of my backers on Patreon. If you enjoy the work on this site, please consider supporting the creation of more content like this by clicking the button.
Time Reef and A Perfect World is one of those Big Finish releases that feels like two entirely different moods taped together and told to behave. It stars Peter Davison at his grumpiest and most exasperated, which is honestly half the appeal, but the results are wildly uneven in a way that feels very Fifth Doctor era in spirit if not always in execution.
Time Reef kicks things off by continuing the Thomas Brewster saga, with the Doctor hunting down bits of the TARDIS that Brewster sold off like stolen bike parts. This leads him to the titular Time Reef, which is exactly what it sounds like. Time is a reef. There are currents. There are eddies. There are conceptual barnacles. I admire the sheer audacity of pitching this in a meeting and watching nobody stop it. The Doctor encounters stranded astronauts, bird people who sound like they wandered in from an off-brand fantasy serial, and a literal tiny princess trapped in a bottle like a cursed novelty gift.
Peter Davison is clearly having fun here, leaning hard into a snappier, crankier Doctor who seems moments away from yelling at the universe to get off his lawn. His delivery elevates a lot of the dialogue, some of which is so earnest and strange it circles back around to being unintentionally hilarious. Out of context clips from this story would sound like performance art. Unfortunately, the story itself never quite gels. It drifts, circles itself, and eventually just sort of ends, leaving the whole reef feeling less like a strange ecosystem and more like a conceptual waiting room. The ideas are playful, the execution is tidy, but it never lands with much impact. By the time it wraps up, you are already forgetting half of it.
Rating: 2 out of 5 bottles containing princesses who did not ask for this.
Then comes A Perfect World, which immediately feels smaller, quieter, and more emotionally focused. The Doctor returns to Earth to find Brewster entangled in the life of a young woman named Tas, who becomes the real centre of the story. Tas stumbles into a parallel version of her own world where everything is perfect, including a flawless version of herself. Naturally, this perfection is hollow, unsettling, and deeply wrong, because Doctor Who is allergic to utopias.
This story uses its limited runtime well. Tas is genuinely likeable, grounded, and sympathetic, and the contrast between her imperfect reality and the eerie perfection of the alternate world works beautifully. Brewster’s ongoing meddling finally catches up with him here, and this is also the story where he exits the series. Honestly, that still stings. Brewster had real companion energy and left just as he was finding his footing. Tas, meanwhile, feels like someone who could have gone on to bigger things, and it is a shame she remains a one-and-done.
Thematically, this half digs into identity, self-worth, and the quiet horror of being told you could be better if you were not yourself. It is restrained, thoughtful, and emotionally effective in a way Time Reef never quite manages.
Rating: 3.5 out of 5 unsettlingly flawless alternate selves who smile too much.