Before continuing, please be aware that all of this content is made possible by the goodwill and support of my backers on Patreon. If you enjoy the work on this site, please consider supporting the creation of more content like this by clicking the button.
The Kingdom of Silver and Keepsake bursts in pretending it is about to redefine Cyberman lore, but actually it is more like being handed a glitter covered toaster and being told it is a mythic relic. This two story release with the Seventh Doctor gives you a taste of chrome soaked ambition, a mouthful of emotional android tragedy, and a big chewy wad of generic Cyberman plot that sticks in your molars long after the taste has faded.
Let us start with The Kingdom of Silver, the longer and significantly wobblier of the pair. The Doctor arrives on Tasak, a technically interesting world full of political schemers and a rigid caste structure still creaking from a recent war. It should feel alive. It should feel like a society on the brink of something profound. Instead half the cast feels like they were generated by typing the words “generic space politician” into a randomizer. Every conversation seems to exist to tell you that something very serious and important is happening, which is usually a sign that nothing serious or important actually is.
The buried Cybermen should be terrifying. Ancient sleepers in the planet’s molten heart. A resource to be harvested, their silver scraped from their bodies and used for medicine by desperate people. That idea alone could have powered an entire story. Imagine exploring a world harvesting its own future conquerors for health tonics. But here it all flashes by like someone waving a cool concept in front of your face only to snatch it away and slam the door. The plot has an unfortunate habit of unfolding exactly how every standard Cyberman story unfolds. The Doctor warns people. People scoff. People die. More Cybermen wake up. Alarms. Conversions. Running. You know the drill.
There are bright spots. The android pair Temeter and Sara add genuine heart and complexity. Their presence hints at the bigger story the script never quite commits to telling. But when the big chrome boys finally rise, the world never feels rooted enough for their threat to matter emotionally. It is spectacle without weight.
Rating: 2 out of 5 malfunctioning Cyber scalpels
Then we hit Keepsake, and I swear the quality whiplash nearly threw my neck out. The Doctor rummages through a junkyard and stumbles on an old memory machine. Inside it he finds the tragic remnants of one of those androids from the previous story. What unfolds is intimate and quietly brutal. A mission gone wrong. A life rewritten. Identity stripped away until only function remains. It is haunting. It is sad. It is everything Kingdom of Silver wanted to be but never dared to stick the landing on.
Keepsake is the point where the themes finally click. Memory. Personhood. War as a machine that eats everyone including its own tools. Humanity reflected in synthetic eyes. It hurts in exactly the right ways.
Rating: 4 out of 5 tragic android tear crystals