Before continuing, please be aware that all of this content is made possible by the goodwill and support of my backers on Patreon. If you enjoy the work on this site, please consider supporting the creation of more content like this by clicking the button.
Three’s a Crowd lands the Fifth Doctor, Peri, and Erimem on a human colony that looks cozy on a brochure, but is actually the black mirror of isolation: people locked in their rooms, living entire lives without human contact. It’s hikikomori meets sci-fi, and when you peel back the existential dread, the planet is run like a macabre petting zoo—with insectoid overlords feeding on the emotionally inert. Ouch.
First, the strengths: the panic narrative, done visceral. Colony residents who freeze at the sight of another person, who flinch when a voice crackles over the intercom—scenes loaded with anxiety. Peri steps in as a makeshift therapist, teaching them breathing techniques, grounding exercises, offering actual human contact as antidote. It’s startlingly compassionate. These character moments lift the story above ‘weird sci-fi premise’ into something oddly tender.
But then—cue the bugs. These alien insectoids are bland hive monsters that feel straight out of the “Big Human-Eating Bug Rulebook.” When your villain is basically “Kromon, but with an extra wobble,” you’ve lost narrative spice. It’s been done. With that cuteness missing, the story limps down to execution.
And about that execution… agonizing. This narrative is a snake biting its own tail. The Doctor splits from his companions early, and you get the same beats twice—a companion finds a locked door, freaks a little, Doctor finds the same door, freaks a little. Repeat. Rinse. No narrative escalation, no surprises—just echo. A two-episode concept stretched painfully to four.
Worse, the story floats beside its own allegory. The colony is basically battery-farmed humanity—caged, human cattle—feeding a monster overlord who profits from emotional starvation. But there’s zero commentary on it. It’s the silent elephant on stage taking all the oxygen while the characters dance around it. With razor-sharp writing, this could’ve been a parable on corporate exploitation or social media addiction.v Instead it remains background elevator music.
Erimem and Peri are decent. Peri’s compassion burns through the script like a flare, Erimem shouts things wisely now and then. The Doctor is, well, the Doctor—slipping between empathy and exasperated detective. Performances hold the script up, but even they can’t rescue the tedium.
Audio design is functional: clicks through doors, that distant insect buzz, claustrophobic hum of the colony at night. But atmosphere alone doesn’t make a story memorable—it just pepper-sprays it with style without substance.
Three’s a Crowd gives you basic sci-fi horror with a sprinkling of empathy—but holds back every time it might bite back. You’re left watching a universe where people are scared to meet, monsters are forgettable, and pacing feels like climbing out of sand.
Final Thoughts:
Solid intentions, terrible follow-through. Not vile. Just… forgettable.
Rating: 2 out of 5 socially anxious human farms.