Before continuing, please be aware that all of this content is made possible by the goodwill and support of my backers on Patreon. If you enjoy the work on this site, please consider supporting the creation of more content like this by clicking the button.
Oh look, a Doctor Who story with no psychic aliens, no ancient prophecies about Time Baby’s return, no ghosts made of data, and no one screaming the word “TIME” like it’s punctuation — just a good old-fashioned historical with actual stakes and no CGI MacGuffin to smother the tension. I almost forgot this was allowed.
The Fires of Vulcan slaps you into Pompeii like someone threw Mel down the wrong chute at the Time-Space Waterpark. It’s hot, it’s messy, and everyone’s going to die — and you feel it. No technobabble, no last-minute vortex resets. Just ash and dread and the soft, terrible crunch of history closing in. The Doctor knows what’s coming. Mel doesn’t. And you, dear listener, get to sit in the middle of that slowly tightening emotional vice and scream internally.
Let’s talk about Mel. No, actually, let’s celebrate her, because Bonnie Langford finally gets something meaty and brilliant to do. Gone is the pastel scream-emoji we were forced to endure on telly. This Mel is smart, empathetic, and completely willing to push back against the Doctor’s fatalism. She sees people suffering and decides to do something about it. Revolutionary! She’s the moral compass without being the designated lecture device. She’s the audience surrogate without being a naive tagalong. I am, for once, pro-Mel. Truly we live in strange times.
And the Doctor — this is one of those stories where McCoy finally clicks into that wounded, weary, chess-master energy he does so well. You can feel the weight on him, pressing down like the ash cloud itself. He’s seen the history books. He knows Pompeii is a death sentence. And it’s eating him alive to stay and watch. But oh gods, does he try.
The supporting cast are all fantastic, too. No faceless cannon fodder here. Everyone’s got motives, regrets, petty ambitions. The slave girl trying to buy her way out of fate, the gladiator with a little-too-much swagger, the desperate innkeeper — it’s like watching a stage play where everyone’s destined to burn and no one knows they’re holding the match. The politics of survival are everywhere, and it’s glorious. And then the lava hits.
That eruption scene? Absolutely gobsmacking. This is where audio earns its keep — you don’t need visuals when the sound design punches you in the gut with every crumbling wall, every screaming citizen, every thunderous death-knell of a civilisation crumbling under fire. It’s not spectacle for spectacle’s sake. It’s tragedy made real.
Honestly, the only reason I’m not giving it a full five is because I reserve that for the ones that emotionally ruin me. This one merely left me shattered and breathing ash.
Final Verdict:
Mel finally gets a real story, McCoy gets to bleed dignity and guilt, and Big Finish remembers that tension is better than technobabble. Pompeii burns, and we feel every second of it.
5 out of 5 doomed Roman holiday postcards